Cassie and Sam's much overdue date doesn't go as planned, and they end up stranded on an island. Joy dreams about her parents.

Cassie and Sam's double date with hospital administrator Grant and his girlfriend, Monica, doesn't go quite as planned. Martha organizes a "Grease" themed movie night in the park.

Cassie, Stephanie and Abigail help Martha throw Claire a baby shower, sparking memories of Cassie's own baby shower.

Sam is excited to perform surgery on a star basketball player. Joy makes a discovery and decides to revive the Middleton Exchange tradition.

Joy's dream sends the three Merriwicks on a search for Phillip Harper, Joy's father.

When Cassie, Abigail, and Joy toss coins into the historic wishing well, wishes old and new start coming true.

As the Merriwicks delve into the images on Joy's vision board, Cassie accompanies Sam on a trip to his childhood home to care for his sister.

Cassie and Sam are disagreeing about his return to work after his shoulder surgery. Flower Universe is trying to undercut Abigail's business, but she won't go down without a fight. Martha and Tom's special anniversary celebration brings all their friends together.

The pressure is on because strange things start happening to Cassie, Abigail and Joy's abilities, adding urgency to finding a Merriwick family heirloom.

Cassie, Abigail, Joy and George come together to protect the Merriwick magic from the mysterious force over Middleton. Cassie and Sam make a momentous decision about their life together.