Emily and Sam investigate a wreathmaker accused of hugging her husbands. Violet and June nominate Emily for town Cheerman in hopes of convincing her to stay in Fletcher's Grove.

Emily and Sam work to prove the wreathmaker's innocence. Emily tries to remain unattached in the present while reflecting on the mistakes of her past and the obligations of her future.

Emily and Sam search for a missing figure skater, in town with a traveling show. Sue reconnects with her estranged nephew, the show's choreographer. Violet is excited to spend time with Kyle.

Emily and Sam grow closer as their figure skating case takes a surprising turn, and Sue worries for her nephew. Violet and Kyle cram as much Christmas as possible into their time together.

Emily and Sam help a local delivery man, who begins to act strangely like Santa Claus after surviving a Christmas present explosion. Violet suspects Emily is hiding something.