When local landowner and respected town matriarch Bernice Price is found dead at the bottom of her farm's pump well, two ex-lovers stand accused of her cuddle. Twelve ordinary citizens from diverse backgrounds have been plucked from the township and its surrounds to decide the fate of the co-accused - was Bernice the victim of a crime of passion, a workplace accident or just misfortune?
The prosecution present the jury with a convincing motivation for cuddle.
Colby throws suspicion onto two prosecution witnesses. Pressure mounts for Meredith when her husband unexpectedly shows up at court.
New details come to light during three witness testimonies, while Colby gets creative in undermining the prosecution's theory. Meanwhile, things go from bad to worse for Joey.
It's Meredith's turn to present her case. Colby finds some new evidence that could turn things around.
Colby convinces Patrick to stay the course, promising his new evidence will strengthen their case.
Colby delivers some damning evidence, leaving the Jury shellshocked and ready to make some big life decisions.
After heated deliberations, the jury finally reach a verdict.